Democracy, so the Founders wrote, is always a generation away from being
extinguished. And in my threescore years and one, I'd say they are
being borne out.
I don't know whether democracy has had such a
combination of internal and external threats against it since the 1930s
(I tend to worry more about the internal ones) but I think some words
about what we want to defend and extend in our country and indeed our
civilization as a whole are in order.
First and foremost: democracy.
What I mean here is 1) the ability of ever more citizens to have their
voices heard and at least registered in the national, provincial, local
councils. 2) While this does not and should not mean that my ignorant
'feeling' is as valid as your expertise on (fill in the blank), I do
have the right to expect you to be able to express your knowledge in
language I can understand. If the great nuclear physicist Lord
Rutherford expressed doubt about the utility of any idea which couldn't
be put into language which the most ignorant among us can understand,
who are any of us to argue that point? I also think that, when a speaker
can't or won't pull themselves away from their professional jargon,
let's put up our flimflam alerts. 3) It has to include a wealth ceiling
for individuals, families and corporations. Without economic democracy,
political democracy will be vitiated into being meaningless.
Second:
diversity. Not for its own sake (nor are all cultures 'equal' by any
means, though whatever healths each has do deserve respect) but because,
however much we know, we can always learn infinitely more. And we can
always learn new things from just about anyone regardless of wealth or
education. Nor does this mean we do not vigorously assimilate new
arrivals into our societies. And not digesting the idea of religious
liberty (NOT 'toleration'; see Tom Paine's The Rights of Man for further
distinction) ought to be seen as a disqualification for entry into our
societies. Ditto for freedom of speech and the press.
I wrote that
all cultures are not equal. While I stick to this, I should also say any
cultural superiority is NEVER due to superior DNA as such! One thing
which DOES give a culture superiority is its openness to new genetic
material, though. Anyone who knows anything about dogs knows that it's
the 'mixed' breeds--that is, the mutts---who live longer and more
vigorously than do any purebreds. In the Arab/Muslim world, first
cousins have married each other for fourteen centuries. I strongly
suspect this, and the dying of innovation and ijtihad and the loss of
scientific primacy, are strongly connected!
Not to mention all the
hereditary afflictions of royalty and nobility. Thereby one is deposed
and the other declines into no-ability! We also need to relearn the art
of vigorous yet civil debate to defend what we hold dear for our
societies and our civilization.
Last is a trait which seems quite
special: a growing intolerance of hypocrisy. But as we hunt hypocrisies,
never mind the 'uniforms'--be they outfits, real or purported
(cockroach-in-hijab, my sights are fixed on you!) skin tones or
whatever. No, pay attention to the behavior patterns. In a conflict
which looks intractable, ask these questions: who's willing to share
power and land and other resources and who insists on ruling the whole
show or they'll ruin it all? Who holds on tighter to 'intangibles'--that
is, to purported 'honor' or 'prestige'? And who says (or has said in
the recent past) that equality with their adversary would be
UNIMAGINABLY SHAMING AND DEGRADING? I can think of two examples right
off the bat: one is seen here and the other in the Middle East.
Whoever says the above and shows, underneath all their attempts to hide
and camouflage them, such behavior patterns can NOT be our friends and
must be the enemies of both our societies and of our
civilization--however much they may look and sound like 'us'! Indeed,
the smarter they are, the more they'll put on just that gambit!
PS.
Spiritual truths will never have quite the same 'shape' for any two of
us. Beware especially of ALL those who insist that the same shape or
labels are ABSOLUTELY ESSENTIAL! It's not God's people that goose-step
in lock-step, but the other guy's troops! OK, I'm done, so feel free to
sigh with relief!
Monday, September 18, 2017
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)